Skip to main content
Back to Blog
Security February 28, 2024

Re-Keying vs. Replacing Your Locks: Which Is Right for You?

Moved into a new home? Had a break-in? We break down the pros and cons of re-keying versus full lock replacement so you can make the best choice.

Two Options, One Goal: Your Security

When it comes to changing your home's security after a move, a lost key, or a break-in, you have two main options: re-keying your existing locks or replacing them entirely. Both accomplish the same core goal - ensuring that old keys no longer work - but they differ significantly in cost, time, and when each makes sense.

What Is Re-Keying?

Re-keying involves changing the internal pins of your existing lock cylinder so that it works with a new key. The lock hardware itself stays in place - only the internal mechanism is modified. This is performed by a locksmith in minutes and is significantly less expensive than full replacement.

  • Costs $20–$50 per lock (labor included)
  • Takes 10–15 minutes per lock
  • Existing lock hardware stays in place
  • Old keys immediately stop working

What Is Lock Replacement?

Lock replacement means removing the entire lock assembly and installing a new one. This is the right choice when your lock is damaged, worn out, outdated, or when you want to upgrade to a higher-security model.

  • Costs $80–$300+ per lock (hardware + labor)
  • Takes 30–60 minutes per lock
  • Opportunity to upgrade lock grade and style
  • Best for damaged or worn hardware

When Should You Re-Key?

Re-keying is the smart choice in most everyday situations where the lock itself is in good condition:

  • Moving into a new home or apartment
  • After a roommate or tenant moves out
  • Lost or stolen keys
  • After a breakup or divorce
  • When you want all locks to use the same key

When Should You Replace?

Full replacement makes more sense when the lock hardware itself is the issue:

  • Lock is damaged, stiff, or difficult to operate
  • Lock was tampered with or shows signs of forced entry
  • You want to upgrade to a higher-security or smart lock
  • Lock is more than 10–15 years old
  • You want a different style or finish

Not sure which option is right for you?

Our locksmiths can assess your current locks and recommend the most cost-effective solution for your security needs.

Share this article

Secure Your Home Today.

Professional re-keying and lock replacement in Evansville, IN and surrounding areas.