Skip to main content
Back to Blog
Technology November 5, 2023

Smart Locks vs. Traditional Locks: Pros and Cons

Smart locks are everywhere, but are they right for you? We compare smart and traditional locks on security, convenience, and cost.

The Lock Landscape Is Changing

Smart locks have gone from a novelty to a mainstream home security product. You can now unlock your door with your phone, a PIN, your fingerprint, or even your voice. But does that mean you should replace your traditional deadbolt? The answer depends on your priorities - and there are real trade-offs on both sides.

Smart Locks: The Pros

Smart locks offer a range of conveniences that traditional locks simply cannot match:

  • Keyless entry - no more fumbling for keys
  • Remote access - lock and unlock from anywhere via app
  • Temporary access codes for guests, cleaners, or contractors
  • Activity logs - see who came and went and when
  • Auto-lock feature prevents accidentally leaving the door unlocked
  • Integration with smart home systems (Alexa, Google Home, HomeKit)

Smart Locks: The Cons

Smart locks also come with real drawbacks that are worth considering:

  • Battery-dependent - dead battery means no entry (most have backup options)
  • Higher cost - $100–$400+ vs. $30–$150 for traditional
  • Cybersecurity risk - connected devices can be hacked
  • Compatibility issues with older door hardware
  • App and firmware updates required for security patches

Traditional Locks: The Pros

Traditional deadbolts and knob locks have stood the test of time for good reasons:

  • No batteries or internet connection required
  • No software vulnerabilities or hacking risk
  • Lower cost and widely available
  • Simple, reliable operation
  • High-security options available (Grade 1, Medeco, Mul-T-Lock)

Traditional Locks: The Cons

Traditional locks do have limitations in today's connected world:

  • No remote access or monitoring
  • Keys can be lost, copied, or stolen
  • No activity log or alerts
  • Sharing access requires physical key duplication

Which Is Right for You?

The best choice depends on your lifestyle and security priorities:

  • Frequent guests or Airbnb hosts - smart lock is a clear winner
  • Tech-averse or reliability-focused - traditional Grade 1 lock is ideal
  • Maximum security - high-security traditional lock outperforms most smart locks
  • Best of both worlds - install a smart lock with a physical key backup

Not sure which lock is right for your home?

Our locksmiths can walk you through your options and install the right lock for your needs and budget.

Share this article

Ready to Upgrade Your Locks?

Smart lock installation and traditional lock upgrades in Evansville, IN.